Interactive tool
Self-propelled vs. pull-type TMR ROI calculator
Payback years, 5-year net impact, savings per ton and per cow per day — with every assumption on the table.
Fleet ROI Summary — Self-Propelled vs. Pull-Type TMR · rmhmixers.com ·
How this is calculated
Extra capital = SP price − pull-type priceLabor = hours saved × wage × 365·Fuel = gal saved × diesel × 365Shrink = herd × feed cost/cow/day × 365 × shrink %Net annual advantage = labor + fuel + tractor/loader offset + shrink − extra SP upkeepPayback = extra capital ÷ net annual advantage·5-year net = 5 × advantage − extra capital- Tons mixed per year assume 115 lbs as-fed per head per day.
How to read the verdict
| Payback | Verdict | Why |
|---|---|---|
| ≤ 4.5 years | Strong self-propelled ROI | Pays back well inside a normal finance term; labor relief and a clean face add up. |
| 4.6–7.0 years | Borderline | Price a late-model used self-propelled against a new pull-type before deciding. |
| > 7 years or negative | Pull-type vertical | Keeps capital free and any backup tractor can run the mixer. |
What the calculator leaves out on purpose
Interest, depreciation schedules and trade-in values differ by farm and lender, so they are not modeled. The biggest risk that is not in the numbers is redundancy: when a pull-type's tractor breaks you hitch another; when a self-propelled's drivetrain goes down, feeding stops unless there is a backup wagon or a dealer close by. Self-propelled machines usually pencil out from about 500–1,000 cows, on multi-site barns connected by road, or where labor is the bottleneck.
Planning estimate only. See terms of use.