TMR mix quality, Penn State Particle Separator & feed shrink
Target particle sizes for a lactating ration, how to spot sorting at the bunk, loading order and mix time, and what 5–15% feed shrink costs.

PSPS targets for a high-producing lactating TMR
The Penn State Particle Separator is a stack of sieves you shake by hand to see how the ration splits by particle length. Targets, as percent of as-fed weight:
Bars show the target band on a 0–100% scale.
Diagnosing sorting
Shake a sample of fresh TMR at feed-out and a sample of refusals before push-up or clean-out. If any sieve shifts by more than 5 percentage points between the two, cows are sorting — typically picking out the fines and leaving long material. Sorting means some cows eat a hotter ration than formulated, which raises the risk of subacute ruminal acidosis (SARA).
Mixer causes of a bad shake
| What you see | Likely mixer cause | Fix |
|---|---|---|
| Too much on the top sieve | Dull or missing knives, short mix time, hay added too late | Sharpen or replace knives; process hay first |
| Too much in the pan | Over-mixing, knives too aggressive, worn kick plates | Shorten mix time; check kick-plate position |
| Batch-to-batch variation | Overfilled tub, worn flighting, inaccurate scale | Load to 60–80% of struck capacity; check flighting and load cells |
Loading order and mix time
- Long dry hay or straw first, processed until it reaches target length.
- Grains, protein and commodities.
- Minerals and small inclusions — into the middle of the load, never against the tub wall.
- Haylage, then corn silage.
- Liquids and wet by-products last.
- Mix 3–5 minutes after the last ingredient, then deliver. Longer is not better.
The cost of feed shrink
Shrink — feed lost to spoilage at the face, wind, tracking, and loader spillage — commonly runs 5–15% between the pile and the bunk. On a 500-cow dairy feeding $8 per cow per day, the annual feed bill is about $1.46 million; saving just 1% shrink is worth $14,600 a year. A clean, tight face (from a milling head or a careful loader operator), covered piles and accurate weighing are where it comes back. Run the ROI calculator with your own shrink figure.